Brough Law

Brough Law from Hartside Hill

Map showing the excursion route, locations and igneous rock types

This excursion, together with the Hartside Hill and Knock Hill excursion, provides opportunities to investigate the rocks resulting from the earliest phase of volcanic activity in the Cheviots. These are the pyroclastic rocks made up of a mixture of the ash, small stones or ‘lapilli’, and larger cobbles or blocks that were thrown out from volcanic vents due to the force of the initial paroxysmal eruptions.
Relatively little has been written about this type of rock in the Cheviots and what information there is mostly concerns the pyroclastic rocks exposed in the upper Coquet Valley in the south-west.
Carruthers, Burnett and Anderson (1932), following Clough (1888) describe the thick bed of agglomerate on Thirl Moor near Makendon as the lowest bed in the whole Cheviot Volcanic Series, resting ‘unconformably upon highly-inclined Silurian strata..’. At the summit of Thirl Moor, they record the thickness of the bed as 200ft (61m) and describing it as silicified breccia. The rock fragments are described as fine-grained mica-felsite (now referred to as biotite-feldspar-phyric trachyte), its colour frequently changed through decomposition into a light pink or dirty yellow. Some of the fragments are recorded as being at least 1.5m long with others, only a little less in size, being quite common The majority of samples were said to show macroscopic as well as microscopic biotite.
More recently, the British Geological Survey have described the same beds, as ‘breccia composed of rubbly, angular to sub angular clasts of silicic volcanic rock, along with some mudstone fragments.’ The Survey reiterates that the Thirl Moor rock, ‘is most likely the product of initial phreatomagmatic eruptions, though a sedimentary origin cannot be entirely discounted.’
Both surveys mention the occasional presence of thinner layers of this type of rock higher in the volcanic succession indicating that, from time to time, the longer periods of quieter eruption of andesitic lavas were interrupted by shorter periods of more explosive eruption.
We wonder how this research relates to the pyroclastic rocks of the Ingram Valley. We have found nothing written specifically about this area even though, according to the BGS online map, these rocks occupy a considerable area. So, here we go.

Location 1. Lapilli-tuff outcrops on the path at NU002163 and NU001163

Brough Law with Knock Hill and Dunmoor Hill behind
The track can be seen leading from the ‘Bulby’s Wood’ car park (behind the trees, right) up Brough Law (left) between the outcrops and the conifer trees (far left).

We park the car along with others at the popular tourist spot ‘Bulby’s Wood’ at NU008163, cross the road and take the track up the hill. We could have taken the longer, more gradually rising route that starts from just outside Ingram. That route would have taken us over Turf Knowe and Ewe Hill but we opt for this shorter one that will take us up to the plantation on Brough Law and then across to the summit. This way, we can take in the exposures by the footpath near the plantation that we saw from the road as we drove in.
Location 1 is a small exposure on the path at NU002163 together with a larger one just above it at NU001163. Both are lapilli-tuff and are surprisingly strong rocks. When polished, the ash and stone fragments that make up the rock become easier to make out. The tuff in the sample from the lower exposure has slightly larger rock fragments than that at the higher one.

Lapilli-tuff at location 1, Brough Law NU002163
Prepared specimen in ordinary reflected light (45mm across)
Lapilli-tuff at location 1, Brough Law NU001163
Prepared specimen in ordinary reflected light (45mm across)

Location 2.  Brough Law hillfort at NT998163

We continue up the path and reach the summit of Brough Law that is crowned by its impressive hillfort.
The fort is a large (68m x 54m) almost circular late-Iron Age settlement bounded by stone walls and banks of rubble. Radiocarbon dating of rampart material has provided a date for commencement of construction sometime between 335-155BC. The massive stone walls of the fort have, over the ages, been robbed for stone, re-arranged for animal pens, and deconstructed during excavations but despite the meddling, archaeologists have a fairly detailed picture of their construction. To the north and west, the fort enjoyed the natural protection of the steep scree slopes – the Ingram Glidders so a double-skinned inner wall 3.5m wide sufficed. Easier access from the south and to some extent from the east required a thicker and possibly a higher inner wall that reached 5.5 m wide at the entrance. Defences were completed by the addition of an outer wall that was approximately 1m wide and the construction of an earthen bank 40m out from the walls to strengthen the southern approach.
Entrances to the east and south were staggered through the walls, the entrance to the east having a causeway that would have originally connected across the ditch. Other gaps in the wall to the north and west are not original. There are definite remains of three hut circles with turf-covered stone walls in the fort. The largest one is almost 9m in diameter and the other two are approximately 5m across. These have been excavated revealing charred wood and fragments of pottery dated between 0 AD and 700 AD and identified as possibly Votadinian and 2nd century Roman. The Votadini were the dominant Celtic tribe of the area, An iron knife was also found and identified as Saxon.

Looking south-east across the hill fort on Brough Law
In the foreground, a lumpy, ground-level outcrop of fine-grained lapilli-tuff with an outcrop of andesite-like rock in the background by the far wall.

Most, if not all, of the rock that outcrops on the slightly domed floor of the fort is tuff, not andesite as is shown on the BGS online map. The map suggests that the whole of Brough Law consists of two layers, an agglomerate/tuff base-layer associated with the early explosive phase of volcanic activity that is topped by a layer of andesite resulting from later effusive lava flows, but this isn’t the case. If there was a cover-all layer of andesite, it has been eroded away at this location. However, this is not to say there are definitely no andesite outcrops to be found up here, but that portion of the rock that looks andesitic could well be an andesitic crystal tuff.
Entering into the fort from the south, there is an exposure just inside the walls that seems to be a mix of obvious ‘lumpy’ looking, weathered tuff and some more angular, dark, andesitic-looking rock. This may be an outcrop of the andesite dyke that is shown on the BGS map running between Knock Hill and Brough Law or it may simply be hard, andesitic tuff – we can’t be sure. The metamorphic effect associated with the heat and compressive force of an intruding dyke or the proximity of a deep overlying cover of lava could explain the hardness of tuff in this vicinity.
The minerals in this dark rock are what we would expect in Cheviot andesite; lots of plagioclase in both the form of large ‘phenocrysts’ and in the form of small laths, ortho- and chino-pyroxene, biotite and iron-titanium minerals. Many of the large plagioclase crystals are broken and embayed and some of the mafic minerals, particularly biotite, have been replaced with chlorite.

Lapilli-tuff, Brough Law NT998163
Prepared specimen in ordinary reflected light (45mm across)
Andesitic-looking rock, Brough Law NT998163 
Prepared specimen viewed in ordinary reflective light (45mm across)
Lapilli-tuff, Brough Law NT998163
Prepared specimen viewed in ordinary reflective light (52mm across)
Broken plagioclase crystal in what is probably an andesitic crystal-tuff
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 4.6 x 3.0 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
Relict biotite, largely replaced by chlorite, and ?pyroxene in andesitic crystal-tuff
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 2.3 x 1.5 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
Altered plagioclase with inclusions andesitic crystal-tuff.
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 2.3 x 1.5 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters

We leave the hill fort via the north-west exit and investigate the many low-lying outcrops..


Location 3. Low-lying outcrops at NT996162

View from location 3 on Brough Law
The Ingram Valley road winds between Hartside Hill (left) and Knock Hill (right) to Linhope. Both hills are substantially tuff and agglomerate and are visited in a later excursion. Cunyon Crags on Dunmoor Hill are visible in the distance. One of a number of low-lying outcrops of tuff is visible in the extreme right foreground.

Again, according to the BGS map, all of the rock in this area should be andesite but we identify most of it as lapilli-tuff but with some parts of outcrops being more fine-grained and having the same andesitic look that we saw earlier.

In thin section, we can see that the larger elements of the tuff are plagioclase crystals with much reduced quantity of, and contrast within, their polysynthetic twinning. They are embayed and full of inclusions that have been subject to alteration. We also see a weak flow structure around them. The rock’s alteration is also evidenced by the numerous patches of chlorite, most likely altered mafic minerals like pyroxenes and biotite, that appear dark blue and brown when viewed under the microscope with crossed polarising filters. Some of the quartz in the rock has the patchy extinction associated with strain.


Specimen 1
Prepared specimen in ordinary reflected light (40mm across)
Thin section from the same specimen viewed in plane polarised light (37mm across)
General appearance of the rock at NT996162
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 4.6 x 3.0 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
General appearance of the rock at location 3
Section viewed with crossed polarising filters (FoV 4.6 x 3.0 mm). The fine-grained portion of the rock is stained brown with iron oxides so that the unstained, larger feldspar crystals appear in clear relief.

Embayed plagioclase crystal with altered inclusions with quartz, Brough Law
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 2.3 x 1.5 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
Embayed plagioclase crystal with altered inclusions along with quartz patches and veinlet 
Section viewed with crossed polarising filters (FoV 2.3 x 1.5 mm)

Weak flow structure around larger elements of the rock
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 2.3 x 1.5 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
Strained quartz in the same thin section
Section viewed with crossed polarising filters (FoV 2.3 x 1.5 mm)

Quartz veinlet next to fractured plagioclase in the same sample
Section viewed with crossed polarising filters (FoV 1.2 x 0.8 mm)

Specimen 2 & 3
Andesite or andesitic crystal-tuff, Brough Law NT997163
Prepared specimen in ordinary reflected light (45mm across)
Andesite or andesitic crystal-tuff, Brough Law NT998163
Prepared specimen viewed in ordinary reflective light (48mm across)
Andesite or andesitic crystal-tuff in the first specimen shown above
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 4.6 x 3.0 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
Andesite or andesitic crystal-tuff in the second specimen shown above
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 4.6 x 3.0 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters

Location 4. Andesitic-looking rock outcropping in crags at NT995162

Andesite-looking rock at Brough Law Crags NT995162

A short walk west and we arrive at location 4, Brough Law’s south-west facing crags at NT995162.
Identification of some of the rock here presents us with same ‘andesite or andesitic crystal-tuff?’ problem. We originally take it to be andesite that has been deposited as lava over tuff, but remembering our doubts about the other, similar rocks we have seen on this excursion, added to the fact that there is a great deal of tuff above the contour of these crags, makes us to look again. More fieldwork reveals that most of these crags are, in fact, lapilli-tuff – the andesitic-looking rock that we have found being restricted to just one location. As at location 2, the hill fort, the surface of this rock looks less lumpy than the surface of the adjacent tuff, the jointing more angular, and the rock darker and more brittle – but we are unable to identify an obvious junction between it and the lapilli-tuff. In the hand, this rock looks similar to the fresh, haematite-veined andesite we have found elsewhere in the Cheviots, but it lacks that rock’s very black and glassy appearance. It could be an andesitic dyke similar to those found on Hartside Hill and Knock Hill on the other side of the valley, possibly mixing with tuff as it was intruded, but perhaps it is a mafic crystal-tuff.
The sample we take has plagioclase crystals measuring up to 5 mm long. In one of these, a haematite-rich veinlet has created interesting micrographic textures.

Andesite, crags at Brough Law, NT995162
Prepared hand specimen in ordinary reflected light (35mm across)
Thin section from the same sample viewed in plane polarised light
The same thin section viewed with crossed polarising filters
General appearance of andesite in the crags at Brough Law Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 4.6 x 3.0 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
Haematite-rich veinlet interacting with a plagioclase phenocryst to produce a micrographic texture in andesite, Brough Law
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 4.6 x 3.0 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
Haematite-rich veinlet interacting with a plagioclase phenocryst to produce a micrographic texture in andesite, Brough Law
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 2.3 x 1.5 mm)

Fine-grained, haematite-rich veinlets in andesite at location 4
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 1.2 x 0.8 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
Haematite-rich veinlet interacting with a plagioclase phenocryst to produce a micrographic texture in andesite at location 4
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 1.2 x 0.8 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
Chlorite with calcite in andesite at location 4
Section viewed with crossed polarising filters (FoV 1.2 x 0.8 mm)

Location 5. Large red boulders

One of a number of large red lapilli tuff boulders on Brough Law NT997160

We contour west across rough ground towards the plantation next to Broughlaw Slack. There are a number of large boulders decorating the hillside in this area, their bright red colour being a consequence of the amount of haematite they contain. Their surface texture is very uneven reflecting their agglomerate origin but why these boulders should be so haematite-rich while others nearby are not is puzzling. We haven’t seen an outcrop of similar rock close by. The rock fragments look like felsite.


Surface colour and texture of the lapilli tuff boulder at NT997160, Brough Law
Lapilli tuff, Brough Law, NT997160
Hand specimen in ordinary reflected light
Lapilli tuff, Brough Law NT997160
Prepared specimen in ordinary reflected light (35mm across)
Thin section from the same specimen viewed in plane polarised light
The same thin section viewed with crossed polarising filters
General view of lapilli tuff, Brough Law
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 4.6 x 3.0 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
General view of the lapilli tuff in the red boulders on Brough Law
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 4.6 x 3.0 mm)

Lapilli tuff, Brough Law
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 4.6 x 3.0 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
Lithic fragments with quartz veining in lapilli tuff, Brough Law
Section viewed with crossed polarising filters (FoV 2.3 x 1.5 mm)5 mm)

Lapilli tuff, Brough Law
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 1.2 x 0.8 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
Lapilli tuff, Brough Law
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 2.3 x 1.5 mm)

Location 6. Outcrop of lapilli tuff

Outcrop of lapilli tuff, Brough Law, NT995160

We cut down the dip by the trees and sample the lapilli tuff that is outcropping here.

Lapilli tuff, Brough Law, NT995160
Prepared specimen in ordinary reflected light (47mm across)

Lapilli tuff, Brough Law, NT995160
Prepared specimen in ordinary reflected light (35mm across)
Thin section from the same specimen viewed in plane polarised light (33mm across)
The same thin section viewed with crossed polarising filters

Location 7. Outcrops along the base of Brough Law

Knock Hill from location 7 at the base of Brough Law NT994162

Picking our way between boulders at the base of Brough Law, we follow the line of the river head back towards the road. On the way we sample more lapilli-tuff at NT994162 and we are rewarded in thin section with a beautiful patch of epidote crystals.


Specimen 1
Lapilli-tuff, Brough Law, NT994162
Prepared specimen in ordinary reflected light (36mm across)
A thin section from the same specimen viewed in plane polarised light
The same thin section viewed with crossed polarising filters
Epidote in lapilli-tuff 
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 1.2 x 0.8 mm).
Note the high relief, glassy appearance, pseudohexagonal crystal form and the transparent yellow-green pleochroism when the polariser is rotated.
Epidote in lapilli-tuff 
The same epidote crystals with the polariser rotated to reveal their pleochroism.
Epidote in lapilli tuff
Section viewed with crossed polarising filters (FoV 1.2 x 0.8 mm)

We continue to skirt around the base of the hill, across the scree and then on a very narrow track that soon becomes wider and finally joins the Ingram-Linhope road by the bridge. There are a number of small exposures of bedrock along the way. The outcrop at NT994163 is andesitic, another at NT995164 is a more recognisable lapilli-tuff, and the last we sample, at NT996165, is, again, andesitic. The isolated nature of the andesitic rock outcrops suggests intrusion as dykes or deposition in a channel rather than deposition in a blanket layer.


Specimens 2, 3 & 4
Andesitic rock at the first outcrop, NT994163
Prepared specimen in ordinary reflected light (52mm across)
Lapilli-tuff at the second outcrop NT995164
Prepared specimen viewed in ordinary reflective light (45mm across)
Andesitic rock at the third outcrop, closest to the road at NT996165
Prepared specimen viewed in ordinary reflective light (43mm across)
Altered biotite in andesite or andesitic crystal-tuff in the first specimen shown above
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 2.3 x 1.5 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
Alteration in andesite or andesitic crystal-tuff in the first specimen shown above
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 4.6 x 3.0 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
The outcrop of andesitic rock nearest to the Ingram-Linhope road at the base of Brough Law, NT996165

Andesite or andesitic crystal-tuff 
Section viewed in plane polarised light (FoV 4.6 x 3.0 mm)
The same area viewed with crossed polarising filters
Embayed and broken plagioclase crystals in the sample taken from the outcrop nearest to the road
Section viewed with crossed polarising filters (FoV 4.6 x 3.0 mm)

At the bridge we have the option of turning left to explore Hartside Hill and Knock Hill, or bearing right to walk back to the car at Bulby’s Wood.


References

Clough C.T., 1888. The Geology of the Cheviot Hills (English Side) HMSO

Carruthers R G, Burnett, G A, Anderson W, and Thomas HH, 1932. The Geology of the Cheviot Hills (Based on the work of C.T. Clough and W. Gunn) HMSO

Stone P. et al , British Regional Geology Northern Britain 5th edition, British Geological Survey, 2010

British Geological Survey Online geology map http://mapapps.bgs.ac.uk/geologyofbritain/home.html

Historic England Brough Law hillfort http://www.pastscape.org.uk/hob.aspx?hob_id=1033854&sort=2&type=hillfort&rational=a&class1=None&period=None&county=None&district=None&parish=None&recordsperpage=10&source=text&p=60&move=p&nor=889&recfc=0





No vestige of a beginning, – no prospect of an end