Tag Archives: Al-Hafdh

Uncategorised

Bellyside Crag and Upper Goldscleugh Sike

We buy a 10.00 GBP day permit from Savills, Glendale Road, Wooler and drive up the College Valley to Dunsdale where we start our walk up Bellyside Hill. The purpose of the expedition is to examine the granitic rock at the northern end of the pluton at Bellyside Crag which is classified by Al-Hafdh and by previous writers as ‘Marginal’ like the rock of Cunyon Crag and Dunmoor Hill on the south east side of the pluton. We also hope to find and examine the andesite outlier mapped at the head of Goldscleugh to see if it gives any clues as to its relationship with the pluton.

Bellyside Hill

View from Bellyside Hill looking up towards Goldscleugh Sike
The ground behind is the summit plateau of the Cheviot.

Bellyside Hill is Cheviot’s closest approximation to a classic ridge walk. Until about 600m there is a good path passing a series of granitic tors on the way. These are composed of a granitic but in appearance mafic rock with occasional felsic intrusions of pink rock.
At about 600m the path disappears and the only way forward is through tiresome blanket bog vegetation.

View looking north down Bellyside Hill showing the outcropping tors

View looking north down Bellyside Hill showing the outcropping tors

View looking north down Bellyside Hill showing the outcropping tors

A felsic phase or dyke in one of the tors on Bellyside Hill

Upper Goldscleugh reveals some rather heavily altered rock which may possibly be andesite, but it occurs as scattered blocks and pebbles, so it is impossible to determine any relationship with the pluton. If it is indeed andesite, its altered state indicates that it must have originated from close to the pluton contact.

We now tramp over to Bellyside Crag. This turns out to be composed of a mafic granitic rock similar to that found on the tors of Bellyside Hill.
The screes around the crag have a large colony of clubmosses.

Thin section of rock from Bellyside Crag viewed with crossed polars at X40

Thin section of rock from Bellyside Crag viewed with crossed polars at X40
Granophyric texture can be seen in several places. There is a large crystal of clinopyroxene at the bottom of the picture.

Subsequent thin section analysis reveals some interesting facts. The rocks of Bellyside Hill and Bellyside Crag are very similar to each other although the Bellyside Hill specimens may have a slightly higher proportion of alkali feldspar. However, neither are anything like the ‘Marginal’ rock of Dunmoor Hill and Cunyon Crag.
The Bellyside Hill specimens have a lower proportion of plagioclase to alkali feldspar (identifiable feldspars show a ratio of about 1:2, plagioclase to alkali feldspar); there is very little biotite, the main mafic mineral being pyroxene (10-15%); quartz content is similar at about 20%. It also has a more marked fine matrix than the southern Marginal with frequent granophyric texture.
It therefore seems rather doubtful that it has the same origin as the southern Marginal rock.

As regards the “andesite” of upper Goldscleugh Sike, if we are correct in identifying this as a granite/andesite contact, both the andesite and granite show clear signs of banding which may indicate contact compression.
Apart from the contact on Shiel Cleugh Edge, this is the only evidence for kinematic action which we have found on Cheviot. Where it exists it appears to be very localised. However, we remain rather uncertain whether the rock from upper Goldscleugh Sike was andesite or just an altered granitic rock.

Uncategorised

Woolhope Crag

Woolhope Crag lies on the north east flank of the Cheviot just above Goldscleugh. It is one of the few convincing outcrops on the Cheviot itself. When we first visited it in 2013, we were looking for, and thought we had found, evidence that the outcrops occur because of the presence of harder, more mafic rock.
Subsequently, we read Al-Hafdh’s thesis which uses Woolhope Crag as the type location for his ‘Woolhope’ variety which is the least mafic, and therefore the most felsic and silica-rich, of his classifications.

Woolhope Crag from the East

Woolhope Crag from the East
The break on the right is where the felsic rock (left) becomes more mafic.

I returned here on19 August 2016 to investigate this apparent contradiction.
The answer is relatively simple. The southern end (higher end) of the crag is felsic; the northern (lower) end is more mafic in appearance. The join occurs at the broken mid-point of the crag. It is not an abrupt contact but a gradual change over about 20 cm and appears at first sight to be an example of fractionation – the first we have discovered in the Cheviot pluton.

Thin section of the upper (more felsic) rock at Woolhope Crag viewed with crossed polars at X40
There are some large phenocrysts of alkali feldspar showing Carlsbad twinning.

This theory breaks down when the two types are compared in thin section.
There seems to be very little difference in content between the two. Thin section analysis suggests that the difference between them is more apparent to the eye in hand specimen than actual. There is a slight increase in plagioclase with the more mafic rock but no increase in mafic minerals (both around 7%). The darker colour is probably due to the smaller grain size of the lower darker rock. Identifiable feldspars in both types show a ratio of about 1:3, plagioclase to alkali. Both types are rich enough in quartz (25-30%) and alkali feldspar to be classified as granite, albeit a relatively fine-grained variety.
An interesting feature of the upper more felsic rock is the presence of frequent chlorite.

Thin section of the lower (‘mafic’) rock at Woolhope Crag viewed with crossed polars at X40
There is no increase in mafic content compared with the more felsic rock. However, the grain size of the matrix is much smaller which must account for the darker appearance.

Uncategorised

Dunmoor Hill

We make a return visit to Dunmoor Hill. The summit tors of the hill present a medium-grained pink granitic rock that look very similar to that of the summit of Hedgehope Hill.
Long Crag (not the same as Long Crags, near Housey Crag in the Harthope valley) reveals a very similar rock. Al-Hafdh classifies the former as ‘Hedgehope granodiorite’ and the latter as ‘Dunmoor granodiorite’. Actually, both in hand specimen and thin section, they are very similar in appearance and mineral content – an observation born out by Al-Hafdh’s own chemical analysis of the types.
We remain unconvinced that they can be separated into two types belonging to separate intrusions.
Al-Hafdh argues that the two are separated by a belt of coarse porphyritic granodiorite (‘Standrop’ variety). A tor containing the coarse rock certainly appears at NT 96890 17969 about half way between the summit and Long Crag, but the extent of peat bog over the hill precludes any way of establishing whether this is part of a wider belt separating the summit of Dunmoor Hill from Long Crag.
A further descent down the south side of the hill reveals again the junction between the pink medium grained porphyritic rock ‘(Dunmoor’/’Hedgehope’) and the dioritic ‘Marginal’ variety.
Cat Crag is definitely composed of the ‘Marginal’ variety.
We look for the hornfelsed andesite that geological map locate close to Long Crag, but we don’t find it.

Uncategorised

Hedgehope Hill

A visit to Hedgehope Hill confirms that the upper Dunmoor Burn contains a very fine-grained granophyric rock. We have provisionally classified this as ‘Evolved’ granite but have since become increasingly doubtful whether it is really part of the same intrusion as the evolved granophyre on the upper slopes of the Cheviot, and whether it really does form part of a ring dyke as Al-Hafdh suggested. Exposure is too limited in the upper Dunmoor Burn to draw definite conclusions.
About 100m below the summit of Hedgehope Hill, the track crosses a large boulder field which is probably the result of periglacial activity. The great majority of these boulders belong to the coarse porphyritic type which Al-Hafdh named ‘Standrop granodiorite’. The summit of Hedgehope has a medium to fine-grained pink rock which is similar to that of Dunmoor Hill. Many samples from the summit show evidence of significant hydrothermal alteration.
Returning via the north side of Hedgehope Hill towards the Harthope valley, we find more of the coarse-grained ‘Standrop’ rock but, after much searching, fail to find the chilled margin between the finer and coarser varieties that Al-Hafdh says is visible there. The one example of really fine-grained rock chilled against the courser rock turns out to be another felsite or aplite dyke.

Uncategorised

Dunmoor Hill

We go to Dunmoor Hill in search of Al-Hafdh’s hitherto elusive chilled margins. Dunmoor Hill is a particularly good site as exposure, unlike in many areas of the Cheviot hills, is plentiful. We are finding Al-Hafdh’s thesis on the Cheviot pluton immensely stimulating. It has provided clear direction to our own research, although we are beginning to doubt his proposal that the Cheviot pluton consisted of a series of ring dykes.
The area below Cunyon Crags has plenty of small outcrops where we find a bewildering mixture of felsic and mafic fine-grained material. At first, we think that the mafic rock is altered andesite. However, thin sections show very well-developed granophyric texture in the felsic rock which imply late intrusion into already established plutonic bodies. The mafic rock has a very high biotite/opaque iron oxide content, and appears to be restite.
Subsequently, we are able to trace the junction between the pink rock (Al-Hafdh’s Dunmoor type) and the more mafic Marginal rocks right across the south slope of Dunmoor Hill. The junction doesn’t show a clear cut boundary but it does present frequent inter-penetration of the two types. The implication is that neither type was fully consolidated when the intrusion took place.
We are still unable to find any chilled margins to confirm an intrusion sequence. Finer rocks always turn out to be aplite veins or small dykes.

Uncategorised

Knock Hill and Upper Linhope Burn

Knock Hill (NT 99584 16499) with its attendant gorge is an impressive feature on the road towards Linhope. It is composed of ignimbrite, and gives evidence that the Cheviot volcanic system was explosive, and produced abundant pyroclastic surges and ash fall, as well as andesite lava flows.
The 1” OS geological map notes a ‘hypersthene-porphyrite’ dyke which we locate at NT 99584 16499 on the south side of the Breamish burn, just beyond the road bridge.
From here, a walk to the upper reaches of the Linhope Burn (around NT 94094 17459) and on to the Standrop Burn. (NT 93794 17839) There is a dacite dyke showing in the streambed just above the two burns’ confluence.
The streambed reveals a variety of rock types. The coarse-grained (Standrop) and finer-grained pink (Dunmoor) varieties in evidence. There is also a much finer grained pale rock similar to the ‘evolved’ granophyre from the Cheviot.
According to Al-Hafdh, this is ‘Woolhope’ granite, part of a ring dyke that circles from the upper Standrop Burn area through to the upper Dunmoor Burn area.

Uncategorised

Al-Hafdh, Linhope Spout and Linhope Burn

We have discovered Al-Hafdh’s 1985 PhD thesis on the alteration petrology of the Cheviot pluton and we’ve decided to chart and verify his rock types.
He claims to have found a series of chilled margins which establish the sequence of the various intrusions.
So, we make an excursion to the Linhope area where we find no convincing evidence for chilled margins but we do find the junction between Al-Hafdh’s Marginal and Dunmoor varieties just above Linhope Spout.
The ‘Felsite’ dyke marked on the 1” OS map at the top of Linhope Spout turns out to be a wider than normal version of the aplite veins which are frequent in the Cheviot pluton. This aplite dyke probably accounts for the hardness of the rock which has caused the waterfall feature.
About 100m up stream there is a slight cliff (about 5m high) at the junction between the pink granite and the marginal. This contains significant quartz veining, lending weight to the theory that hydrothermal activity took place along lines of weakness between the two types. Thin sections from this area reveal red crystals in the quartz which we first identified as rutile but now think more likely to be hematite.
Up stream to NT 94694 17249, we find a course-grained porphyritic rock in the streambed which Al-Hafdh classified as ‘Linhope’ granodiorite. We are not convinced by his differentiation of this from ‘Standrop’ granodiorite, and can not find evidence for a chilled margin between them.